Skip to main content

Nerdio is Microsoft’s 2026 Americas ISV Partner of the Year Get the story

Nerdio Manager for MSP

Three MSP myths the data killed

Sabrina Dhaliwal | November 18, 2026 | 5 min read

We were wrong about tool sprawl. 

Tool consolidation has been a part of how we describe our product value proposition for years. We commissioned this research to validate what we believed about the MSP market and margin levers, and we ended up with 3 data points that countered traditional assumptions and even proved one of our key narratives about margin wrong. 

It would be easy to just gloss over those findings and move on, but we're publishing them anyway because we also want to share the margin levers that do matter. 

Myth #1: Configuration drift is a vendor invention 

Before we conducted the survey, we interviewed a few senior MSP operators on their own hypotheses about the MSP market. One of them, a director of technical services, thought configuration drift was a vendor invention, calling it “a new thing, probably the last three to six months," and suspected vendors were "trying to find a way to make some money there." 

In our survey, 18% of respondents did describe configuration drift across their environments as more of a vendor talking point than a real problem. But this was vastly overshadowed by the 71% of MSPs who described drift as either an occasional issue or a real, ongoing operational pain point.   

This tells us that while configuration drift is not felt across the board yet, it is a real hurdle for the vast majority of MSPs and it’s worth watching as EUC becomes increasingly complex.  

Myth #2: Standardization is what keeps customers 

We went in believing that standardizing customer environments is what keeps those customers long-term. After all, one of Nerdio Manager’s best capabilities is standardization across tenants with policy baselines, solution baselines, and golden templates. 

But when we asked for the biggest drivers of retention, MSPs ranked responsive support first, and standardization last – behind pricing and migration friction. Another one of our participants explained why: “If I just eliminate a customer’s problems, that’s not going to extend their tenure with me… It really comes down to account management and communication and relationship building." 

And when you think about it from the customer’s point of view, this seems obvious. What customers can judge is whether someone picks up the phone at 4pm on a Friday, or fixes their ticket before they have to follow up. Your configuration baselines, while helpful to you, are invisible to them. That doesn’t mean they’re worthless though. In our last blog, we discussed the market factors that put pressure on MSP growth – one of them being engineer burnout. Standardization earns its place as a capacity discipline that can ease the burden on your team.  

Myth #3: Tool sprawl is eating your margin 

And here’s the one that disproved our value proposition. The typical MSP runs 7-10 tools to manage Microsoft 365 and Azure across their customer tenants. This wasn’t surprising to us given how many point solutions exist. And we’ve historically pitched Nerdio Manager against these point solutions with messaging focused on eliminating tool sprawl as a measure to protect margins. But it turns out this isn’t really a problem that MSPs have: there is no correlation between the number of tools an MSP uses and their gross margin – MSPs running 11 or more tools report gross margins that are no worse than those running 10 or fewer.  

So that begs the question then: what does move margin? 

What does move margin 

We found two levers that track with margin: what you can justify to a customer, and what you turn on for them.  

Among MSPs who struggle to articulate their value to customers, more than half of them cannot clear above 40% gross margin. Likewise, the more licensed features MSPs leave idle, the harder it is to clear 40% margin.  If you can’t articulate your value, you won’t be able to justify your pricing. And if customers pay for capabilities they never receive, they’re getting overcharged and they’ll eventually notice.  

So here’s the actual margin equation: forget about tool count; instead, focus on communicating what you offer to customers, delivering every feature they pay for, and staying responsive.  

Of course, there’s one more factor that separates the MSPs who scale from those who don’t. In part three, we’ll look at the three different ways MSPs operate, and why one operating model stands above the rest. 

Watch the on-demand webinar for the full findings, or download the market intelligence report. 

About the research: findings come from a survey of 153 MSP decision-makers responsible for managing Microsoft 365 and Azure across customer accounts, fielded June 22 to July 7, 2026 by Thrive Analytics for Thirdside and commissioned by Nerdio. Results were analyzed across seven firmographic cross-breaks, including how MSPs manage Microsoft: native tools, community and open-source tooling, or a commercial multi-tenant platform. Segment differences are significance-tested at 95% confidence. Operator quotes come from in-depth interviews conducted in April and May 2026, lightly edited for readability. 


About the author

Sabrina Dhaliwal

Senior Product Marketing Manager

Sabrina Dhaliwal is a Senior Product Marketing Manager at Nerdio focusing on go-to-market strategy, product messaging, and sales enablement for managed service provider solutions. Prior to Nerdio, Sabrina was a Senior Strategy Consultant, where she advised Fortune 500 clients on tech modernization, new product launches, and user experience. In her spare time, she volunteers as a web developer for a non-profit and speaks about AI and professional networking at community events.

Ready to get started?